Fonterra’s decision to sell its entire consumer products arm—the Mainland Group—to Lactalis has triggered a firestorm in New Zealand, and analyst Geoff Fischer is leading the charge with a blistering critique. In his view, the cooperative hasn’t just trimmed some fat; it has cut into bone—national economic bone.
Selling a Nationally Strategic Asset to a Global Giant
Fonterra was created by Parliament and dominates the backbone of the country’s export economy. Fischer argues that when a business with that kind of national footprint sells off a major unit, every New Zealander is indirectly on the hook for the long-term consequences.
Political leaders may shrug and say, “It’s a shareholder decision.” Fischer says: not when the entire country depends on dairy for income, jobs, and tax revenue.
Risking New Zealand Jobs for a Short-Term Balance Sheet Glow
The sale includes major brands—Anchor, Mainland, Kapiti—and three critical New Zealand processing sites. The most jarring line in Lactalis’ announcement?
4,300 staff will be integrated into the “Lactalis Australia workforce.”
Translation: New Zealand’s plants risk becoming mere satellite factories reporting to Australia. And since Lactalis has zero legal obligation to keep production in New Zealand, closures are not paranoia—they’re precedent. Lactalis has shut plants before, including a major one in Italy in 2023.
The “First Folly”: Chasing High Margins at the Expense of Strategic Diversity
Fonterra’s justification is that the consumer business delivers lower returns than commodity milk powder.
Fischer’s counterpunch:
If you chase only the highest-return commodity, you eventually hollow out your industry.
New Zealand’s forestry sector did exactly that, shifting to cheap logs and abandoning higher-value processing—an economic own goal the country is still paying for.
Concern About Lactalis’ Track Record
Fischer doesn’t mince words. Lactalis has a history peppered with:
- A$950k fine for breaching Australia’s Dairy Code of Conduct
- €11.69m fine in Spain for cartel behavior
- Ongoing tax fraud investigations in France
Handing a chunk of New Zealand’s dairy value chain to a company with this résumé? “Unwise” is the polite phrasing.
The Raw Milk Supply Agreement: A Trojan Horse?
Fonterra must supply 350 million liters of milk a year for at least a decade—about 7% of its output. But nothing requires Lactalis to turn that milk into New Zealand-branded consumer goods at New Zealand factories.
They can ship it, dry it, mix it, dilute it, or rebrand it anywhere they want.
The “Second, Third, and Fourth Follies”
Fischer groups the other strategic blunders into a trio:
The Second Folly: Losing Vertical Integration
Fonterra gives up control over that section of the supply chain—ceding customer access, market intelligence, and processing security.
The Third Folly: Future Dependence on a Global Monopsonist
After 10 years of compulsory supply, Lactalis could simply walk away. Fonterra’s farmers would then be dangerously exposed to market volatility and contract bargaining from a global behemoth that now controls a piece of their map.
The Fourth Folly: Ignoring Domestic Spillover Benefits
Local processing plants don’t just make butter—they make:
- jobs
- tax revenue
- community economic stability
- transport and logistics activity
- regional development
Lose value-added processing, and these vanish. Fischer predicts many sites could be shuttered inside the decade.
The Bottom Line
In Fischer’s view, Fonterra hasn’t made a business decision—it has made a national strategic mistake. The cooperative gains a quick financial tidy-up but risks sacrificing:
- domestic jobs
- processing sovereignty
- long-term value creation
- supply chain security
- and New Zealand’s global dairy independence
Join Our “Dairy & Food Jobs Updates” WhatsApp group
Disclaimer
I do my best to share reliable and well-researched market insights but occasional errors or omissions may slip through. Please view all content as informational, not financial advice.
Stay informed on all the latest news updates
All Agriculture Books Free Download
All Dairy Technology Books Free Download
All Agricultural Engineering Books Free download
All Horticulture Books Free Download
All Fisheries Science Books Free Download
For Daily Update follow us at:
Facebook Telegram Whatsapp Instagram YouTube
The contents are provided free for noncommercial purpose such as teaching, training, research, extension and self learning.
If you are facing any Problem than fill form Contact Us
If you want share any article related Agriculture with us than send at info@agrimoon.com with your contact detail.
